Check out one of our other posts:

January 26, 2018

OnePlus 5 Quick Review and Case Comparison - Guest Post

Here at Fiscally Free, we don't like spending a fortune on cell phones (or anything, really), which is why we love OnePlus. They make great phones and charge a lot less than the competition. What's not to love? Chrissy and I both have a (used) OnePlus One, and even though it came out almost four years ago, it still works great. My friend and former coworker Mitch is also a fan of OnePlus, and he recently upgraded from a OnePlus One (OPO) to a OnePlus 5 (OP5). He offered to write a post about his thoughts on the new phone and several cases he got for it, so here it is.

Editor's note:  This post is very pro-OnePlus, however, it is NOT sponsored content. We are simply big fans of their phones. However, we have included referral links to OnePlus which will give you $20 off accessories and give us "referral points" if you buy a phone.
Also, we know the OnePlus 5 has been discontinued and replaced by the OnePlus 5T. That just means you can find a better deal on a used OP5, like my friend did.
Finally, OnePlus has had some recent security issues with their site, so proceed with caution.

OnePlus 5 Review (vs. the OnePlus One)
Editor's Note #2:  I will warn you, Mitch is incredibly picky about his phone, so be prepared for some neurotic engineer nitpicking. Here are his thoughts on how the OP5 compares to the OPO:

I bought a used OP5 because I wanted to get a fast phone with a button on the front and a headphone jack--a lot of the newer phones have moved the button to the back and eliminated the headphone jack.

I was still 90% satisfied with my OPO; it is fast enough for me but the camera is lacking, so I have to carry a point and shoot when traveling. Also I’ve been looking for a new phone for my girlfriend, so “new phone” has <unnecessarily> been on my mind.

How the OP5 is better than the OPO
  • Fast. Crazy fast.
  • Camera is way way better and takes pics almost instantaneously.
  • Fingerprint reader prevents accidental home button presses while typing.
  • USB-C is great, and the adapters are only $6 for 5 adapters on Amazon.
  • Has a hardware slider switch for ring/vibrate/silent, however, the positions are not intuitive and you can’t reconfigure them.
  • Headphone jack is on the bottom next to the usb-c plug, so when it is in the car holder all cords exit downwards (less stress on the cords and jacks).

How the OP5 is equal to the OPO
  • Both Good:  Capacitive buttons (instead of onscreen buttons like the newer phones).
  • Both Good:  Phenomenal battery life.
  • Both Bad:  Vibration is still weak like the OPO.
  • Both Bad:  I still accidentally hit the capacitive back button while typing sometimes.

How the OP5 is worse than the OPO
  • Fingerprint reader doesn’t act as a true button--it only works if you use a finger that has been scanned, and it only holds 5 fingerprints.
  • Screen is curved at the edges--requires a special wraparound screen protector to get full screen coverage.
  • Some cases can peel the wraparound screen protector off. I’m afraid to take the phone out of the case now.
  • Phone is narrower overall--if you are a guy with full sized hands the phone feels narrow. I like OPO width better.
  • Software isn’t as refined or as customizable as the Tugapower ROM on the OPO.
  • It’s under warranty, so no rooting yet. That means I can't block advertisements.

The Best (Cheap) OnePlus 5 Case
In his quest to find the perfect (affordable) case for his new phone, my friend bought four different cases. Here are his thoughts on them.

Pros:
+ Very grippy to the touch
++ Reinforced corners

Cons:
- Clear back has poor appearance
-- Plasticy finish, not rubber
-- Terrible tactile key feel

Conclusion: Poor key feel, cheap appearance, avoid.


I didn’t want a kickstand model, I just wanted something that was very grippy. This looked grippy.
Pros:
+ Soft rubber with a plastic outer shell
+ Nice key feel
+ Actually works better WITHOUT the hard plastic shell--edges are easier to grip

Cons:
- Tire tread appearance is cheesy
-- Kickstand feature protrudes significantly
--- Case edge is in the exact wrong spot and it PEELS BACK FACTORY OP5 screen protector! 

Conclusion: AVOID if you have the factory wrap around screen protector


Pros:
++ Excellent key feel, by far the best of the four
+ Gripper texture on sides is somewhat effective
+ No cutout for Oneplus logo = less dirt

Cons:
- Faux carbon fiber back inserts are hokey
- Plain rubber back is slippery
- Case barely sticks up above screen--limited protection
- Case is thin overall and corners are not reinforced
- Tough to pull out of jean pocket compared to the others

Conclusion: A good basic case that works right out of the box


Pros:
++ Case sticks up above screen protector, offers good protection
+ Corners are slightly bulged
+ Gripper slots on edge
+ “Brushed” finish on back offers a little bit more grip than plain rubber of the Tudia case

Cons:
-- Key tactile feel is poor 
- Reinforced edge around the screen lacks gripper slots--case is much more slippery
- Reinforced edge protrudes further out than the keys, making key presses extra difficult
- Volume slider is tough to get to because case is thick in the corner area
- Faux carbon fiber back inserts are hokey

Mixed:
+/- Cutout for Oneplus logo will let dirt into the case, but also gives another spot to grip
+/- Raised lip on back of phone offers good protection, but scoops up dirt and lint out of your pocket 


So what case did I end up using? The Biuzko, but with a whole bunch of modifications.


Biuzko Modifications
Mod 1: Used a cutoff wheel (Dremel) to put a ton of gripper notches in the upper edge of the case. This was the biggest improvement.

Mod 2: Used an X-Acto knife to clearance the rubber around the slider.

Mod 3: Used an X-Acto knife to slice along the power and volume buttons to allow for better tactile feel. I did this in a few stages to get the feel where I wanted it.

Mod 4: Used the cutoff wheel to clearance the edge above the power button to allow easier access. I didn’t clearance the volume button side, as I use the volume buttons much less often than the power button.

Was this interesting? Do you want to see more random product reviews? Let us know in the comments.


Affiliate Recommendation:
Track your phone savings with Personal Capital
When you save a bundle by purchasing a OnePlus, you are going to want to track that money. Personal Capital makes it fast, easy, and secure. Best of all, it's FREE. Here at Fiscally Free, we use Personal Capital and we recommend you try it today. You'll be glad you did.

No comments:

Post a Comment